Nothing too exciting happenned at the exam. The format was open book, open notes. Needless to say that even with this format I felt a brain-freeze, as oftentimes the case in my quantitative classes. Will see how I fared on the forced grading curve. The stuff covered in the exam was all the material we have studied so far in the class: sampling distribution, confidence interval, hypothesis testing. All the stuff that makes people excited, myself including
I wish I also had a better grasp on it.
Speaking of the better grasp. Earlier in the module I asked professor if he could recommend some other book which could be used to better understand the concepts we learn in the course and their application. Surprizingly, professor admitted he was not specifically excited about the textbook we were using, but it had been the department’s choice, not his. So he recommended another book.
I earnestly hoped it would be some other kind of book, not another graduate level statistics textbook, which I already had. I hoped for something a bit more on a layman, or at least undergraduate level. I thought, he might wholeheartedly endorse something from Complete Idiot’s Guide to… series, or from the … for Dummies collection. A-hem. Apparently he does not read this kind of books, at least not on statistics.
So he recommended me a book. I was so desperate about my struggles with statistics that I ordered it right away on Amazon. When it arrived soon after and, I opened the package… it was yet another textbook on statistics at graduate level
. I admit, it has a huge advantage, about 30% advantage to be more precise: it has only about 800 pages vs almost 1100 pages in our required textbook for this statistics course. I actually read side by side a few definitions from both books, just to see if it is really better/easier explained in my new acquisition. I can not tell. I think that some stuff is explained a bit clearer in one, whereas other explanations are a bit more conceivable in the other book. On the right, by the way, is the new book I am talking about.
Now I have two textbooks on statistics. What I don’t have is the time to read them both. So I will use them for cross-reference in especially difficult cases. And for straight reading I would stick with the new one, even if for the sake of its “brevity” :).
I will even throw in for free this business idea for left-brainers with entrepreneurial inclinations (even though we all know it’s usually not going together. You are either entrepreneur or a left-brainer. Just kidding): how about creating a series of cartoon/comics level books on all quantitative core MBA courses? Come to think of it, why not to have cartoon/comics books on all qualitative MBA classes for those struggling left-brainers too
. Forget Complete Idiots’ and Dummies series – too complicated. We need comics! :-0
And staying true to my MBA credo, I rescind that free offer. I will take a few copies of each book for personal use as a small token of appreciation for this great idea.



{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }
Very interesting post.
I’m a professor at Texas Tech University and I’ve written the first graphic novel management book. The book incorporates key management theories (rather than the fads often incorporated into many popular business books), but without the boring prose common to so many academic books or textbooks.
Action! Mystery. Romance. Odd jobs?
Mediocre college student Atlas Black works to fund his college expenses, start a new business, and court favor from his ex-girlfriend. With the help of his quick witted sidekick, adorable local barista, sage management professor, and a mysterious advisor known only as “Black”, Atlas Black provides a whole new meaning to the term ‘business time.’
Businessweek coverage
http://www.businessweek.com/bschools/blogs/mba_admissions/archives/2010/03/tktktk_2.html
Wall Street Journal coverage
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704869304575110051869245646.html
Chapter 1 available to view free online
http://www.flatworldknowledge.com/node/15264
Wikipedia page
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_Black:_Managing_to_Succeed
YouTube ‘movie’ trailer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FIeXdP0Hq2A
Available now on Amazon.com
http://www.amazon.com/Atlas-Black-Managing-Jeremy-Short/dp/098236184X
“It very well could be that this year’s best business book is a comic book!” – Duane Ireland, Distinguished Professor and Bennett Chair, Texas A&M University
Thanks for the comment, and the links.
I am actually planning to do a follow up post on this subject. After writing this article I found a few other supplementary books suitable for MBA students made in cartoon/comics format. Your book is definitely going to be among recommended.